首页 > 其他分享 >Does One Have to be a Genius to Do Maths? (必须是天才才能做数学吗?)

Does One Have to be a Genius to Do Maths? (必须是天才才能做数学吗?)

时间:2024-05-12 17:08:36浏览次数:12  
标签:Do who hard Genius Does understand they mathematics ordinary

This is a question that many people talk about. And I think it is important because incorrect responses can mislead individuals and significantly influence his/her attitude to studying mathematics.

Let me quote the following two to express my opinion.

The answer is an emphatic NO. In order to make good and useful contributions to mathematics, one does need to work hard, learn one’s field well, learn other fields and tools, ask questions, talk to other mathematicians, and think about the “big picture”. And yes, a reasonable amount of intelligence, patience, and maturity is also required. But one does not need some sort of magic “genius gene” that spontaneously generates ex nihilo deep insights, unexpected solutions to problems, or other supernatural abilities. ---Terry Tao

You ask me if an ordinary person—by studying hard—would get to be able to imagine these things like I imagine. Of course. I was an ordinary person who studied hard. There's no miracle people. It just happens they got interested in this thing, and they learned all this stuff. They're just people. There's no talent or special miracle ability to understand quantum mechanics or a miracle ability to imagine electromagnetic fields that comes without practice and reading and learning and study. So if you take an ordinary person who's willing to devote a great deal of time and study and work and thinking and mathematics, then he's become a scientist. --- Richard P. Feynman

Both scientists agree that one does not "magical" or "miracle" talent to be a scientist. Maybe you will argue that these two persons (Tao and Feynman) are already geniuses, they just don't understand how hard for an ordinary person to follow their thoughts. If you have such an opinion, I have to say you are wrong. If you understand in detail how they think and teach, you will find that they surprisingly know ordinary people too well! (I should put some examples here.)

And I can understand that, there are plenty scientists who are very good at researching or publishing papers, but their lectures are so messed up that it’s hard for normal students to understand. (I have lots of such experiences as a student, to be honest.) This may create the illusion that only geniuses can understand mathematics. But in fact, these hard-to-understand people are not doing well in some sense of mathematics. Here I refer readers to the article What is good mathematics, which discusses many aspects of mathematical ability.

You may still argue that I just collected something that support my opinion and ignored others's objections. You're right, there are also many domestic mathematicians who warn that if you don’t have a high IQ, don’t study mathematics, or don’t choose mathematics as your major. Believe it or not, these kind of researchers say like that probably because they don’t know how to teach an absolute beginer, they think their explanation is very well which is far from the truth. I have lots of words to speak out here, but I'd better keep polite. After all, I'm just an ordinary student who has no paper in PhD period yet (if you really care).

However, what I believe is: Every thing in mathematics can be understood, if only I pay enough time into it like Feynman said. Learning mathematics and understanding mathematics is itself a wonderful experience, which is irrelevant to anything else.

Reference

标签:Do,who,hard,Genius,Does,understand,they,mathematics,ordinary
From: https://www.cnblogs.com/crossLH/p/18187961

相关文章

  • Docker 部署Redis
    1、创建Redis目录mkdirRedis目录2、创建配置文件redis.confvimRedis目录/redis.conf#当配置中需要配置内存大小时,可以使用1k,5GB,4M等类似的格式,其转换方式如下(不区分大小写)#1k=>1000bytes#1kb=>1024bytes#1m=>1000000bytes#1mb=>1024*1024byt......
  • Docker 部署MySQL
    1、创建配置目录mkdir-pMySQL目录/conf2、切换到配置目录cdMySQL目录/conf3、创建配置文件vimmy.cnf[client]#设置mysql客户端连接服务端时默认使用的端口port=3306default-character-set=utf8mb4[mysql]#设置mysql客户端默认字符集default-character-set=ut......
  • 精简 Windows 系统可能会带来以下影响和危害:
    精简Windows系统的影响和危害取决于精简的程度以及用户的具体需求和使用情境。一般来说,精简Windows系统可能会带来以下影响和危害:功能受限:精简Windows系统通常会去除一些预装的应用程序、服务和功能,这可能会导致部分功能无法正常使用或者无法满足特定的需求。兼容性问......
  • linux模拟windows尝试
    windowswinehttps://github.com/winegui/WineGUIlookingglasshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eTWf5D092VYwinappshttps://nowsci.com/#/winapps/?id=installationmacosdarling跟wine一样,做转义层仅支持shell和一个很老的macOS文件管理器https://docs.darlinghq.org/......
  • Docker Compose 备忘清单
    DockerCompose备忘清单Docker-compsoe是一个开源项目,用于定义和运行多容器Docker应用程序的工具。由Docker社区维护。通过一个YAML文件来配置应用程序的服务,以便可以使用一个命令启动、停止和重启整个应用程序。DockerCompose开源地址DockerCompose发行地址github......
  • 如何编译Godot(Godot & Godot with C#)
    要在Windows下编译Godot,需要以下环境:VisualStudioCommunity:使用最新版本。MinGW-w64:可以替代VisualStudio。请务必将其安装/配置为使用posix线程模型。使用MinGW编译主分支时,需要GCC9或更高版本。Python3.6+:确保在安装程序中启用将Python添加到环境变量......
  • MajorDoMo RCE(CNVD-2024-02175)
    影响平台MajorDoMo<0662e5e漏洞复现fofa搜索语法:app="MajordomoSL"POC:GET/modules/thumb/thumb.php?url=cnRzcDovL2EK&debug=1&transport=%7c%7c%20%28%65%63%68%6f%20%27%5b%53%5d%27%3b%20%65%63%68%6f%20%31%32%33%3b%20%65%63%68%6f%20%27%5b%45%5d%2......
  • Windows Server 2025 简体中文版下载 (Inside Preview, updated May 2024) - 下一代 W
    WindowsServer2025简体中文版下载(InsidePreview,updatedMay2024)-下一代Windows11ServerWindowsServer2025正式版发布在即请访问原文链接:WindowsServer2025简体中文版下载(InsidePreview,updatedMay2024)-下一代Windows11Server,查看最新版。原创......
  • USB 设备相关的注册表项通常存储在 Windows 操作系统的注册表数据库中。这些注册表项
    USB设备相关的注册表项通常存储在Windows操作系统的注册表数据库中。这些注册表项包含有关连接到计算机上的USB设备的配置信息。以下是一些常见的USB设备相关的注册表项:HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Enum\USB:这个键包含有关已连接到计算机的USB......
  • Windows hosts 文件是一个文本文件,用于将主机名与相应的 IP 地址进行映射。这个文件通
    C:\Windows\System32\drivers\etc\hosts是一个计算机上的文件路径,通常用于存储主机名与IP地址之间的映射关系。在Windows操作系统中,这个文件被称为"hosts"文件。这个文件的作用是将主机名映射到相应的IP地址,这样当你在浏览器中输入一个域名时,系统会首先查看这个文件......